Challenges in evaluating childhood bereavement services
The theoretical and practical issues
Keywords:
Childhood bereavement, childhood bereavement services, evaluation, outcomes, methodologiesAbstract
AbstractThis paper discusses the evaluation of childhood bereavement services in the UK policy context and some of the challenges this presents. Two key difficulties are discussed: the lack of any clear, agreed outcomes from bereavement interventions with children, and the challenge of evaluating the complex social processes that bereavement interventions involve. Two recommendations are made to address these in the short term and to generate data for wider research. These are: to strengthen services' existing evaluation strategies, and to develop a routine evaluation package that can be used by all services. This would comprise a basic data set, a user satisfaction questionnaire, and a childhood bereavementfocused clinical outcome routine evaluation measure. In the longer term, further research is recommended, including UK-based longitudinal studies.
References
Abdelnoor, A and Hollins, S. 2004. The effect of childhood bereavement on secondary school performance. Educational Psychology in Practice, 20(1): 43–54.
Avis, J. 2003. Work-based knowledge, evidence-informed practice and education. British Journal of Educational Studies, 51(4): 369–389.
Axford, N and Berry, V. 2005. Exploring the potential of shadow: controls in the evaluation of children's service. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 8(5): 389–404.
Beresford, B, Tozer, R, Rabiee, P and Sloper, P. 2007. Desired outcomes for children and adolescents with autistic spectrum disorders. Children & Society, 21: 4–16.
Boswell, G. 1995. Violent victims: the prevalence of abuse and loss in the lives of Section 53 offenders, London: Prince's Trust.
Bowlby, J. 1998. Attachment and loss. Vol 3: Loss, sadness and depression, London: Pimlico.
Chowns, G. 2009. “Swampy ground: brief interventions with families before bereavement”. In Brief interventions for bereaved children, 2nd ed, Edited by: Monroe, B and Kraus, F. 37–51. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Christ, G. 2000. Healing children's grief: surviving a parent's death through cancer, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Christ, GH, Raveis, V, Siegel, K and Karus, D. 2005. Evaluation of a preventive intervention for bereaved children. Journal of Social Work in End of Life and Palliative Care, 1(3): 57–81.
Cohen, JA, Mannarino, AP and Knudsen, K. 2004. Treating childhood traumatic grief: a pilot study. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 43(10): 1225–1233.
Currier, JM, Holland, JM and Neimeyer, RA. 2007. The effectiveness of bereavement interventions with children: a meta-analytic review of controlled outcome research. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, 36(2): 253–259.
Curtis, K and Newman, T. 2001. Do community-based support services benefit bereaved children? A review of empirical evidence, Child: Care. Health and Development, 27(6): 487–495.
Dowdney, L. 2000. Childhood bereavement following parental death. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 7: 819–830.
Easton, C. 2002. “Foreword”. In I can't stop feeling sad: calls to Childline about bereavement, Edited by: Cross, S. London: Childline.
Eedle, S. 2003. “Evaluation”. In CBN Bulletin Issue 5, London: National Children's Bureau.
Harrington, R and Harrison, L. 1999. Unproven assumptions about the impact of bereavement on children. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 92: 230–233.
Hill, AB and Hill, ID. 1991. Principles of medical statistics, 12th ed, London: Edward Arnold.
Horowitz, S, Leaf, P and Leventhal, C. 1998. Identification of psychosocial problems in pediatric primary care: do family attitudes make a difference?. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 152: 367–371.
Kingson, ER. 2005. Lessons from Joan. Living and loving with cancer – a husband's story, Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.
Kmietowicz, Z. 2000. More services needed for bereaved children. British Medical Journal, 320(1): 893–893.
Maclean, M and Wadsworth, MEJ. 1988. The interests of children after parental divorce: a long-term perspective. International Journal of Law and the Family, 2: 155–166.
McAlister FA , van Diepen S , Padwal RS , Johnson JA , Majumdar SR 2007 . How evidence-based are the recommendations in evidence-based recommendations? PLoS Med 4 (8) e250 [online]. Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17683197?dopt=Abstract [accessed 11 September 2008] ].
Melvin, D and Lukeman, D. 2000. Bereavement: a framework for those working with children. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 5(4): 520–539.
Nugus D 2009 . Choosing life . Counselling Children and Young People March 32 37 .
Nugus D , Stokes J 2007 . Bridging the gap: 15 years of service development and delivery. A model for community-based child bereavement services in the UK . Grief Matters Winter 36 41 .
Oakley, A. 1990. “Who's afraid of the randomized controlled trial?”. In Women's health counts, Edited by: Roberts, W. 167–194. London: Routledge.
Øvretveit, J. 1998. Evaluating health interventions, Philadelphia: Open University Press.
Potts, S, Farrell, M and O'Toole, J. 1999. Treasure weekend: supporting bereaved siblings. Palliative Medicine, 13(1): 51–56.
Ribbens McCarthy, J. 2006. Young people's experience of loss and bereavement: towards an interdisciplinary approach, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Rolls, L. 2007. Mapping evaluations of UK childhood bereavement services. Final report to the Clara E Burgess Charity, Cheltenham: University of Gloucestershire.
Rolls, L. 2008. “Families and children facing loss and bereavement. Childhood bereavement services: a diversity of models and practices”. In Palliative care nursing: principles and evidence for practice, 2nd ed, Edited by: Payne, S, Seymour, J and Ingleton, C. Buckingham: Open University Press.
Rolls, L and Payne, S. 2003. Childhood bereavement services: a survey of UK provision. Palliative Medicine, 17: 423–432.
Rolls, L and Payne, S. 2004. Childhood bereavement services: issues in UK provision. Mortality, 9(4): 300–328.
Rolls, L and Payne, S. 2007. Children and young people's experience of UK childhood bereavement services. Mortality, 12(3): 281–303.
Rolls, L and Payne, S. 2008. The voluntary contribution to UK childhood bereavement services: locating the place and experiences of unpaid staff. Mortality, 13(3): 258–281.
Rolls, L and Penny, A. 2011. Mapping evaluation of UK childhood bereavement services: findings from a recent study. Bereavement Care, 30(1): 43–47.
Rosner, R, Krause, J and Hagl, M. 2010. A meta-analysis of interventions for bereaved children and adolescents. Death Studies, 34: 99–136.
Rowling, L and Holland, J. 2000. Grief and school communities. The impact of social context: a comparison between Australia and England. Death Studies, 24: 35–50.
Smith, G and Cantley, C. 1985. Assessing health care: a study in organisational evaluation, Milton Keynes: Open University Press.
Stokes, J. 2009. Resilience and bereaved children: helping a child to develop a resilient mind-set following the death of a parent. Bereavement Care, 28(1): 9–17.
Stokes, J and Crossley, D. 1996. “Camp Winston: a residential intervention for bereaved children”. In Interventions with bereaved children, Edited by: Smith, S and Pennells, M. 172–192. London: Jessica Kingsley.
Stokes, J, Pennington, J, Monroe, B, Papadatou, D and Relf, M. 1999. Developing services for bereaved children: a discussion of the theoretical and practical issues involved. Mortality, 4(3): 291–307.
Stokes, J, Wyer, S and Crossley, D. 1997. The challenge of evaluating a child bereavement programme. Palliative Medicine, 11: 179–190.
Sweeting, H, West, P and Richards, M. 1998. Teenage family life. Lifestyle and life chances: associations with family structure, conflict with parents and joint family activity, International Journal of Law. Policy and the Family, 12(1): 15–46.
Tones, K. 2000. Evaluating health promotion: a tale of three errors. Patient Education and Counselling, 39: 227–236.
Victora, CG, Habicht, J-P and Bryce, J. 2004. Evidence-based public health: moving beyond randomized trials. American Journal of Public Health, 94: 400–405.
Williams, J, Chaloner, J, Bean, D and Tyler, S. 1998. Coping with loss: the development and evaluation of a children's bereavement project. Journal of Child Health Care, 2(2): 58–65.
Worden, J. 1996. Children and grief: when a parent dies, New York: Guilford Press.
Worswick, J. 2000. A house called Helen: the development of hospice care for children, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Youth Justice Trust 2003 . On the case: a survey of over 1,000 children and young people under supervision by YOTS in greater Manchester and West Yorkshire . Manchester : Youth Justice Trust .
